For this Literacy Circle meeting, my job was the discussion director. These are the questions which I came up with:
1. To who do you think the journal which Ben wrote was meant for?
- I think the journal was written for Salamanca because Ben hangs out with her a lot.
- I think the journal was written for either Salamanca of Phoebe because Ben might like either of them.
- I think it was for Salamanca because Ben loves Salamanca and he kissed her o the ear.
2. What do you think this message means: We never know the worth of water until the well is dry?
- I think that it means that we never know the qualities of life until they are taken away.
- I think it means to conserve water.
- I think it means that we never know the worth of objects until they are gone.
3. Did anything surprise you about this section of the book?
- Yes. It surprised me that Phoebe and Salamanca were gathering more and more clues and getting more messages.
- It surprised me that Phoebe and Salamaca found out more about the lunatic including his name.
4. What do you think is going to happen next?
- I think that it will turn out that the lunatic isn't a lunatic after all.
- I think that it be clear of who wrote the strange messages.
5. What is your favorite part of the book so far?
- I like the part where the teacher reads the journals because of all of the emotions going on.
- I like the part where the teacher reads the poem because it really is a poem to think about.